Google and Yahoo dominate the booming online
search advertising business,
which is expected to grow to $5.6 billion in 2008, from $2.7 billion in
2004. Profit from search advertising enabled Google to more than double
its revenue in 2004, to $3.1 billion.
The concept — text ads that appear next to search results — works on a
"pay-per-click" model. Advertisers pay only if someone clicks on an ad.
To use the programs, advertisers buy "keywords" for anywhere from 5
cents to $100 a word. Those are the terms people type into query boxes
when they're searching, such as "Atlanta wedding photographer" or "Omaha
Italian restaurants."
AdSense works as a part of that
keyword model; it's an offshoot of what Google calls its
AdWords program, which competes against Yahoo's Overture unit.
AdSense is a bonus program for advertisers who use
Google AdWords. Through
AdSense, Google clients get to tout their wares beyond
Google's home page — potentially reaching more than 200,000 participating Web sites.
Small Web site operators have flocked to
AdSense as a way to
attract advertising. To participate, they sign up at Google, which
reviews the site. Once a small piece of computer code language is
implanted on an accepted site,
Google does the rest — matching ad links from its warehouse of clients to appropriate sites.
There's an art to
optimizing a site to attract more links — and generate more revenue.
Gay Gilmore, who runs Seattle-based recipezaar.com, says the trick is to
attract ads next to recipes beyond the main page. "The ads need to be
targeted," she says, "so that when someone is reading about chicken
soup, an ad for one of the ingredients is of keen interest."
Web site publishers need to be creative, says Dave Lavinsky of
TopPayingKeywords, an
AdSense advice
site. A house painter advertising his services on a homemade site is
leaving money on the table if he mentions only house painting, he says.
"'Housepainting' is a 20-cent word. 'Home improvement' is worth $2, so
you should create content for that."
But Sullivan says keyword tricks hurt the editorial integrity of sites.
Another problem, he says, is the proliferation of computer-generated
directories with links to hotels, restaurants and entertainment and no
real editorial content, fueled by the availability of "
Ads by Google" checks.
Wojcicki says Google tries to review all sites in its program, and
removes offenders such as the directory sites. Critics say the site
reviews can sometimes result in an FCC-like "family friendly" filter.
Bloggers complain about being rejected for discussions of sexuality and
use of four-letter words.
"I begged, argued and appealed to reason for months," says author Susie
Bright, whose site discusses sexuality issues. "I pointed out that all
my postings were things you could easily read in ... any number of
mainstream magazines that cover politics from a fairly sophisticated
point of view. And I pointed out that my readers like to buy trousers,
go on vacations, purchase ink and basically buy all the same things that
everyone else does."
Wojcicki wouldn't address the specifics of Bright's concerns, but says
AdSense isn't
for everyone. "We're very careful about who we let into our network. We
reject sites with content some people may feel uncomfortable about."
With pay-per-click ads,
Google and Yahoo are locked in a
bitter battle for advertiser dollars. But Yahoo doesn't compete with
AdSense for small publishers — yet. Yahoo says it will introduce an
offering later this year.
For now, Google's most notable
AdSense competitor is privately
held Kanoodle, which accepted Bright's site. It works with small
publishers and big ones (including USATODAY.com and MSNBC) and differs
from
AdSense in that advertisers can choose topic areas of the sites where they want their ads to appear.
"The search advertising market is red hot right now, and publishers and
advertisers want more," says Kanoodle CEO Lance Podell. "We offer them
more places to show their ads, and they love that."
Adsense Top Paying Keywords